A belief in God could lead to a more contented
life, research suggests.
Religious people
are better able to cope with shocks, such as losing a job or divorce, claims a study
presented to a recent Royal Economic Society conference.
Data from
thousands of Europeans revealed higher levels of "life satisfaction"
in believers.
However,
researcher Professor Andrew Clark from the Paris School of Economics, said other aspects of a religious
upbringing unrelated to belief may influence future happiness. ”What we found was that religious people were
experiencing current day rewards, rather than storing them up for the future”.
This is not the
first study to draw links between religion and happiness, with a belief among
many psychologists that some factor in either belief, or its observance,
offering benefits.
Professor Clark and
co-author Dr Orsolya Lelkes from the European Centre for Social Welfare Policy
and Research, used information from household surveys to analyze the attitudes
of Christians - both Catholic and Protestant - not only to their own happiness,
but also to issues such as unemployment.
Their findings,
they said, suggested that religion could offer a "buffer" which
protected from life's disappointments.
Professor Clark
said: "We originally started the research to work out why some European
countries had more generous unemployment benefits than others, but our analysis
suggested that religious people suffered less psychological harm from
unemployment than the non-religious. "They had higher levels of life
satisfaction".
Even though
churchgoers were unsurprisingly more likely to oppose divorce, they were both
less psychologically affected by marital separation when it did happen, he
said.
"What we
found was that religious people were experiencing current day rewards, rather
than storing them up for the future."
However, he said
that the nature of the surveys used meant that undetected factors, perhaps in
the lifestyle or upbringing of religious people, such as stable family life and
relationships, could be the cause of this increased satisfaction.
The precise
contribution of religion to mental health remains controversial, although there
is other evidence that it does directly improve happiness, said Professor Leslie
Francis, from the University of Warwick.
He said that the
benefit might stem from the increased "purpose of life" felt by
believers.
He said:
"These findings are consistent with other studies which suggest that
religion does have a positive effect, although there are other views which say
that religion can lead to self-doubt, and failure, and thereby have a negative
effect. The belief that religion damages people is still in the minds of
many."
Terry Sanderson,
president of the National Secular Society, which represents the interests of
atheists and agnostics, said that studies purporting to show a link between
happiness and religion were "all meaningless".
"Non-believers
can't just turn on a faith in order to be happy. If you find religious claims incredible,
then you won't believe them, whatever the supposed rewards in terms of personal
fulfillment.
"Happiness is
an elusive concept, anyway - I find listening to classical music blissful and
watching football repulsive. Other people feel exactly the opposite. In the
end, it comes down to the individual and, to an extent, their genetic
predispositions."
But Justin
Thacker, head of Theology for the Evangelical Alliance, said that there should
now be no doubt about the connection between religious belief and happiness.
"There is
more than one reason for this - part of it will be the sense of community and
the relationships fostered, but that doesn't account for all of it.
"A large part
of it is due to the meaning, purpose and value which believing in God gives
you, whereas not believing in God can leave you without those things."
BBC News, March 19, 2008
|